The December Birthstones: A Comparative Guide to Turquoise and Blue Topaz

December is a month marked by cold weather, festive cheer, and the joy of birthdays. For those born in this month, the tradition of assigning a birthstone offers not only a symbol of personal identity but also a piece of natural history and cultural richness. The December birthstones are among the most diverse and beautiful in the calendar year, and two of them—turquoise and blue topaz—stand out for their deep blue hues and contrasting histories. This article delves into the properties, origins, symbolism, and practical care of these two gemstones, helping readers understand the distinctions between them and make informed choices when selecting December birthstone jewelry.

History and Lore

Turquoise: An Ancient Gemstone

Turquoise has a history that stretches back thousands of years. It is one of the oldest known gemstones, with evidence of its use dating back to ancient Egypt, Persia (modern-day Iran), and China. The Egyptians referred to turquoise as "the stone of the gods," and it was often used in jewelry, amulets, and even in the inlays of furniture and ceremonial objects. In ancient times, it was believed to possess protective qualities and was used as a talisman against evil spirits and misfortune.

Turquoise has also played a significant role in Native American cultures, especially among the Navajo, Pueblo, and Hopi tribes. These indigenous peoples have long valued turquoise for its spiritual and healing properties, incorporating it into their jewelry and sacred rituals. The stone was believed to bring good luck, health, and strength, and was often used in ceremonies to connect with the natural world and the divine.

Turquoise’s status as the traditional December birthstone is well established. It has long been associated with the month and is recognized in many historical birthstone charts. In addition to its spiritual significance, turquoise is also the gemstone for the 11th wedding anniversary, symbolizing friendship and fidelity.

Blue Topaz: A Modern Discovery

In contrast to the ancient history of turquoise, blue topaz is a relatively modern addition to the list of December birthstones. While topaz in general has been known since antiquity, blue topaz in particular is a product of modern gemstone enhancement techniques. Natural blue topaz is extremely rare, and most of the blue topaz available in the jewelry market is created by heat treatment or irradiation of colorless or brownish topaz.

The discovery and popularization of blue topaz as a December birthstone is a more recent development. It was officially recognized as a December birthstone by the American Gem Society and other gemological authorities in the late 20th century, adding to the already diverse list of December gems. The stone quickly gained popularity due to its affordability, durability, and striking blue color, which is reminiscent of the winter sky.

Blue topaz is also the state gemstone of Texas, further cementing its cultural significance in the United States. It is associated with calmness, love, and clarity, making it a fitting symbol for the introspective and often serene nature of the winter season.

Geological Formation and Sources

Turquoise: A Porous, Hydrated Phosphate

Turquoise is a phosphate mineral with the chemical formula CuAl₆(PO₄)₄(OH)₈·4H₂O. It is a hydrous mineral, meaning it contains water within its structure, and it is also porous, which makes it more susceptible to damage from chemicals and physical abrasion. This porosity also allows turquoise to absorb dyes and resins, which is why many turquoise stones on the market are stabilized or dyed to enhance their color and durability.

Turquoise is formed in hydrothermal veins and weathered deposits, typically in arid regions where copper-rich rocks are exposed to the elements. The best-known sources of turquoise include:

  • Iran (Persia): Long considered the source of the finest turquoise, especially the "Persian blue" variety.
  • United States: Particularly in New Mexico, Arizona, and Nevada, where turquoise has been mined for centuries.
  • Mexico: Known for its high-quality turquoise, especially from the Cananea and Taxco regions.
  • China, Tibet, and Chile also produce turquoise, though the quality and color can vary.

The color of turquoise can range from sky blue to greenish blue, depending on the presence of copper (blue) and iron (green) in the stone. The most valuable turquoise is typically deep blue with black matrix veins, which add character and contrast.

Blue Topaz: A Versatile Silicate

Blue topaz is a silicate mineral with the chemical formula Al₂SiO₆. It is one of the hardest gemstones, with a Mohs hardness of 8, making it highly durable and suitable for everyday wear. However, it is important to note that natural blue topaz is extremely rare. Most of the blue topaz available in the market is either heat-treated or irradiated to enhance its color.

Topaz is found in a variety of geological environments, including:

  • Granite pegmatites and metamorphic rocks
  • Volcanic rocks, where it can form in cavities and fissures

The most significant sources of topaz include:

  • Brazil: The largest source of topaz in the world, with high-quality material found in Minas Gerais and Bahia.
  • Afghanistan, China, and Russia also produce topaz, though the color and clarity can vary.
  • Natural blue topaz is found in Northern Ireland and the UK, but these deposits are limited.

Blue topaz is prized for its clear, sky-blue to deep London Blue color, which is often enhanced through heat treatment. The process involves heating colorless or brownish topaz to high temperatures, which alters the crystal structure and produces a vibrant blue color. This makes blue topaz one of the most affordable and accessible blue gemstones on the market.

Gemological Properties

Property Turquoise Blue Topaz
Chemical Formula CuAl₆(PO₄)₄(OH)₈·4H₂O Al₂SiO₆
Color Blue to greenish blue Sky blue to deep London Blue
Hardness (Mohs) 5–6 8
Luster Waxy to greasy Vitreous
Transparency Translucent to opaque Transparent to translucent
Cleavage Poor to none Poor to none
Stability Porous and sensitive to chemicals Stable and durable
Common Treatments Dyeing, stabilization with resins Heat treatment to enhance color
Origin Iran, USA, Mexico, China, Chile Brazil, Afghanistan, China, Russia, UK

From a gemological standpoint, blue topaz is the more durable and stable option, making it ideal for everyday jewelry. Its high hardness and resistance to scratches make it less likely to require special care. In contrast, turquoise is more delicate and requires careful handling to avoid damage from chemicals, moisture, and abrasion.

Symbolism and Metaphysical Beliefs

Turquoise: A Stone of Protection and Wisdom

Throughout history, turquoise has been regarded as a stone of protection, wisdom, and healing. In ancient cultures, it was believed to have the power to ward off evil spirits and bring good fortune. The Egyptians used turquoise in their amulets and burial masks to ensure safe passage to the afterlife.

In Native American traditions, turquoise is considered a spiritual stone that connects the earth and sky. It is often used in ceremonial rituals and jewelry to invoke protection, clarity, and strength. It is also believed to promote inner peace, calmness, and emotional healing, making it a popular choice for those seeking balance and tranquility.

Modern metaphysical beliefs also attribute healing properties to turquoise, including the ability to soothe anxiety, enhance communication, and promote self-expression. It is often used in energy healing practices and is believed to stimulate the throat and third eye chakras, enhancing intuition and spiritual awareness.

Blue Topaz: A Stone of Calm and Clarity

Blue topaz is often associated with calmness, clarity, and emotional healing. It is believed to help individuals release negative emotions, overcome fears, and gain a sense of inner peace. In modern gemstone lore, blue topaz is also associated with love, fidelity, and friendship, making it a fitting symbol for the December birthstone.

In spiritual traditions, blue topaz is believed to enhance communication and self-expression, making it a valuable stone for those who struggle with anxiety or social interactions. It is also believed to promote wisdom and intuition, helping individuals make clear and rational decisions.

Some sources suggest that blue topaz can enhance creativity and inspire new ideas, making it a popular choice for artists, writers, and musicians. Its calming properties are also believed to reduce stress and promote emotional balance, making it a valuable tool for meditation and self-reflection.

Care and Cleaning

Turquoise: Delicate and Porous

Due to its porous nature, turquoise requires careful handling and storage to maintain its color and integrity. It is sensitive to chemicals, moisture, and abrasion, which can cause it to lose its color or become damaged.

To care for turquoise jewelry:

  • Store it in a dry, airtight container to prevent moisture from seeping into the pores.
  • Avoid exposure to lotions, perfumes, and cleaning products, as these can cause discoloration.
  • Clean it gently with a soft, dry cloth. Avoid using ultrasonic cleaners or steamers, as these can damage the stone.
  • Remove turquoise jewelry before swimming, exercising, or applying cosmetics.

If turquoise becomes dull or discolored, it can be polished with a soft cloth and mild soap. However, it is important to avoid using abrasive materials or harsh chemicals, as these can damage the surface of the stone.

Blue Topaz: Durable and Easy to Care for

Blue topaz is easier to care for than turquoise due to its high hardness and stability. It is not porous and is resistant to scratches, making it ideal for everyday wear.

To care for blue topaz jewelry:

  • Clean it with a soft cloth or a mild soap solution. A soft-bristled brush can be used to remove dirt from the stone and setting.
  • Ultrasonic and steam cleaners are safe to use, as long as the jewelry is free of any inclusions or treatments that could be affected by high heat or vibration.
  • Store it in a jewelry box or pouch to prevent scratches from other gemstones.
  • Avoid exposing it to extreme heat, as this can cause the color to fade or change.

Blue topaz is also resistant to chemicals, making it less likely to be damaged by lotions, perfumes, or cleaning products. However, it is still a good idea to remove it before applying cosmetics or engaging in activities that could expose it to harsh chemicals.

Conclusion

December is a month of celebration, reflection, and joy, and its birthstones—turquoise and blue topaz—capture the spirit of the season in their own unique ways. Turquoise, with its ancient history and deep blue hues, represents wisdom, protection, and spiritual connection, while blue topaz, with its modern discovery and vibrant color, symbolizes calmness, clarity, and emotional balance.

For those born in December, choosing between these two gemstones can be a matter of personal preference, cultural significance, and practicality. Turquoise offers a rich historical and spiritual legacy, while blue topaz provides durability, affordability, and a stunning blue color that is ideal for everyday wear.

Whether you are drawn to the timeless allure of turquoise or the modern elegance of blue topaz, both gemstones offer a beautiful and meaningful way to celebrate the month of December.

Sources

  1. All About December Birthstone
  2. December Birthstones
  3. December Birthstones for the month of December
  4. December Birthstone Guide
  5. Dazzling December Birthstone Guide
  6. December Birthstone Article
  7. December Birthstones: Blue Topaz, Zircon, Tanzanite, Turquoise

Related Posts