Alternative September Birthstones: A Gemological Exploration of Sapphire, Lapis Lazuli, and Carnelian

September, the month of transition between summer and autumn, is symbolically rich with change and harvest. In the realm of birthstones, September holds a special place, with sapphire as its primary gemstone. However, the lore and practice of birthstones extend beyond the singular representation of sapphire, with several alternative gemstones recognized and celebrated in different cultures and historical periods. These alternatives—lapis lazuli and carnelian—carry their own distinct geological, cultural, and symbolic significance, making them worthy of deeper exploration. This article delves into the gemological properties, historical associations, and metaphysical beliefs surrounding these three stones, with a focus on the sources and evidence provided by reputable materials in the field.


Sapphire, the principal September birthstone, is a gem of enduring beauty and symbolic depth. A member of the corundum family, sapphire ranks a 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, second only to diamond. Its deep blue coloration is typically attributed to trace amounts of iron and titanium within the crystal structure. While blue is the most iconic shade, sapphires can occur in a range of colors, including pink, yellow, green, and even colorless. The name "sapphire" comes from the Greek word sappheiros, meaning "blue stone," a reference to the most widely recognized variety.

Sapphires have long been associated with wisdom, nobility, and truth. Their use in royal regalia and high society is well-documented, with notable examples such as the Ceylon sapphire featured in Princess Diana’s engagement ring. The gemstone’s durability and chemical resistance make it ideal for everyday wear, while its historical and cultural significance lend it an air of regality. Sapphires are mined in various parts of the world, including Myanmar (formerly Burma), Thailand, India, and Madagascar, with each location producing stones with unique color and clarity characteristics.


Lapis Lazuli: The Stone of the Cosmos

Lapis lazuli, the first alternative birthstone for September, is a striking blue metamorphic rock composed of several minerals, with lazurite being the most significant. This mineral is responsible for the stone's characteristic deep blue color, which is often enhanced by flecks of gold-colored pyrite and white calcite. To qualify as lapis lazuli, a rock must contain at least 25% lazurite, ensuring that the dominant blue hue remains prominent.

Historically, lapis lazuli was highly valued in ancient civilizations. It was used as a pigment, a material for sculpture, and a decorative gemstone. Notably, it adorned the sarcophagus of Pharaoh Tutankhamun and was a favored material in the Russian court of Catherine the Great. In medieval and Renaissance Europe, lapis lazuli was often ground into a fine powder to create the ultramarine pigment, a costly and highly prized blue used in religious paintings and manuscripts.

In terms of gemological properties, lapis lazuli is a relatively soft stone, ranking between 5 and 6 on the Mohs scale. This makes it more susceptible to scratches and damage compared to sapphire, but still harder than glass. As a semi-precious stone, it is often used in jewelry and decorative objects where its beauty can be appreciated without excessive wear.

Metaphysically, lapis lazuli is associated with communication, illumination, and spiritual insight. It is believed to promote mental clarity, serenity, and a connection to the divine. Some ancient cultures even mistook it for sapphire due to its similar blue coloration and regal appearance. Today, it is regarded as a stone of the throat and third eye chakras, aiding in the expression of truth and the expansion of spiritual awareness.


Carnelian: The Stone of Confidence and Creativity

Carnelian, the second alternative September birthstone, is a vibrant red-orange variety of chalcedony. Its coloration is primarily due to the presence of iron impurities within the quartz structure. The name "carnelian" derives from the Latin word carneus, meaning "flesh-like," a reference to its warm, reddish tones.

Carnelian has a hardness of 7 on the Mohs scale, making it more durable than lapis lazuli but still less hard than sapphire. It is often used in jewelry and carvings, particularly for cameos and intaglios, where its smooth texture and rich coloration make it an ideal material. In terms of historical use, carnelian was highly valued in ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia, where it was used in seals and amulets. In modern times, it is associated with fertility, confidence, and abundance.

Metaphysically, carnelian is believed to stimulate creativity, courage, and motivation. It is linked to the sacral and solar plexus chakras, supporting emotional balance and personal power. Some sources suggest that carnelian has the ability to "cleanse" other stones, enhancing their energetic properties. It is also considered a protective stone, often placed near a home's entrance to welcome good fortune and positive energy.

Carnelian is found in various locations around the world, including Brazil, India, and the United States. The most prized specimens come from the state of Arizona, where the stone is known for its deep red and orange hues. In jewelry, carnelian is often cut into cabochons or faceted to enhance its color and luster.


Historical and Cultural Significance

The historical and cultural significance of these September birthstones is vast, with each stone having played a unique role in various civilizations. Sapphires, with their association with royalty and wisdom, have long been symbols of power and prestige. Their use in crowns, scepters, and other royal insignia reflects their status as a gemstone of the elite.

Lapis lazuli, on the other hand, has a more mystical and spiritual connotation. Its association with the cosmos, as reflected in the flecks of gold that resemble stars, has made it a favored stone in religious and philosophical contexts. In ancient Egypt, it was used in the adornment of the dead, believed to facilitate the soul's journey in the afterlife. In medieval Europe, it was considered a stone of divine wisdom, often used in the creation of sacred art.

Carnelian, with its warm and vibrant coloration, has been associated with vitality and courage. In ancient Rome, it was used in the creation of signet rings, which were used for sealing documents and as symbols of authority. In Hindu and Vedic traditions, carnelian is considered a protective stone, believed to bring good fortune and ward off negative energies.

These historical uses and associations have contributed to the enduring popularity of these stones as birthstones. While sapphire remains the most widely recognized September birthstone, the inclusion of lapis lazuli and carnelian as alternatives reflects the diverse cultural and spiritual traditions that have influenced the practice of birthstone selection.


Geological Formation and Sources

The geological formation and sources of these gemstones provide further insight into their unique properties and availability. Sapphires are formed under high-pressure and high-temperature conditions deep within the Earth's crust. They are typically found in igneous and metamorphic rocks, with major sources including Myanmar, Thailand, and Madagascar. The presence of trace elements such as iron and titanium gives sapphires their characteristic blue coloration, while other elements can result in a wide range of colors.

Lapis lazuli is a metamorphic rock that forms through the transformation of sedimentary rocks under high pressure and temperature. It is composed of lazurite, calcite, and pyrite, with the proportion of each mineral affecting the stone's color and value. The most valuable lapis lazuli is found in Afghanistan, where it has been mined for thousands of years. Other sources include Russia, Chile, and Canada.

Carnelian is a form of chalcedony, a microcrystalline variety of quartz. It is formed through the deposition of silica in cavities and fissures within rocks, with iron impurities responsible for its red and orange coloration. Carnelian is found in a variety of locations around the world, with notable sources including Brazil, India, and the United States. The most prized specimens come from Arizona, where the stone is known for its vibrant color and clarity.

The availability of these gemstones in different parts of the world has contributed to their historical and cultural significance. The trade and exchange of these stones across regions and civilizations have facilitated the spread of their symbolic meanings and uses, making them an integral part of human history.


Symbolism and Metaphysical Beliefs

The symbolism and metaphysical beliefs associated with these gemstones reflect their deep cultural and spiritual significance. Sapphires have long been associated with wisdom, nobility, and truth. In many ancient cultures, they were believed to possess divine properties, capable of bringing clarity and insight to the wearer. In medieval Europe, sapphires were considered symbols of divine favor and were often used in religious and royal settings.

Lapis lazuli is associated with spiritual insight, mental clarity, and divine wisdom. It is believed to promote a sense of calm and serenity, making it a valuable stone for meditation and spiritual practices. In ancient Egypt, it was used in the adornment of the dead, believed to facilitate the soul's journey in the afterlife. In medieval Europe, it was considered a stone of divine wisdom, often used in the creation of sacred art.

Carnelian is associated with vitality, courage, and motivation. It is believed to stimulate creativity and emotional balance, making it a valuable stone for those seeking to express themselves and achieve their goals. In ancient Rome, it was used in the creation of signet rings, which were used for sealing documents and as symbols of authority. In Hindu and Vedic traditions, carnelian is considered a protective stone, believed to bring good fortune and ward off negative energies.

These symbolic and metaphysical associations have contributed to the enduring popularity of these gemstones as birthstones. While sapphire remains the most widely recognized September birthstone, the inclusion of lapis lazuli and carnelian as alternatives reflects the diverse cultural and spiritual traditions that have influenced the practice of birthstone selection.


Care and Cleaning

The care and cleaning of these gemstones depend on their physical properties and the type of jewelry in which they are set. Sapphires are highly durable and can be cleaned with a soft cloth and mild soap in warm water. They are resistant to heat, light, and chemicals, making them ideal for everyday wear. However, it is important to avoid exposing sapphires to sudden temperature changes, as this can cause internal stress and potential damage.

Lapis lazuli, being a relatively soft stone, requires more delicate care. It should be cleaned with a soft cloth and mild soap in warm water, avoiding harsh chemicals and abrasive materials. Due to its susceptibility to scratches and damage, it is best to store lapis lazuli jewelry separately from harder gemstones and to avoid wearing it during activities that may cause impact or abrasion.

Carnelian is more durable than lapis lazuli but still requires careful handling. It can be cleaned with a soft cloth and mild soap in warm water, but should be avoided from prolonged exposure to heat and direct sunlight, as this can cause the color to fade. It is also advisable to avoid using ultrasonic cleaners for carnelian, as the vibrations can cause micro-fractures in the stone.

Proper care and maintenance can ensure that these gemstones retain their beauty and value over time. By understanding their physical properties and care requirements, gemstone enthusiasts can enjoy the unique qualities of these stones for years to come.


Conclusion

September’s birthstones—sapphire, lapis lazuli, and carnelian—each carry a unique blend of historical, cultural, and gemological significance. While sapphire remains the most widely recognized September birthstone, the inclusion of lapis lazuli and carnelian as alternatives reflects the diverse traditions and beliefs that have influenced the practice of birthstone selection. These gemstones not only offer aesthetic beauty but also serve as symbols of wisdom, vitality, and spiritual insight.

Through their geological formation, historical use, and metaphysical properties, these stones continue to captivate and inspire. Whether worn as jewelry, used in spiritual practices, or simply admired for their beauty, sapphires, lapis lazuli, and carnelian hold a special place in the world of gemstones. Their enduring appeal is a testament to the deep connection between humans and the natural world, a connection that has been celebrated for centuries across cultures and civilizations.


Sources

  1. September Birthstone – Farmers’ Almanac
  2. September Birthstone: Sapphire, Two Alternative Birthstones – Matthew's Jewelers
  3. September Birthstone – A Complete Guide – IL Gemstones
  4. September Birthstones – Crystal Life
  5. Birthstone – Wikipedia

Related Posts