Who Decides Birthstones: The Historical and Cultural Origins of Birthstone Assignments

The concept of birthstones—gemstones associated with specific months and their wearers—has captivated people for centuries. These gemstones are more than mere adornments; they carry historical, cultural, and symbolic significance. But who decided which gemstone belongs to which month? The answer lies in a complex interplay of religious texts, ancient traditions, and modern commercial interests.

This article explores the origins and evolution of birthstone assignments, focusing on the key institutions and cultural influences that have shaped the modern list. Drawing from historical texts, religious references, and contemporary practices, we will uncover how birthstones came to be standardized and what role various cultures and organizations have played in this process.

The Ancient Roots of Birthstones

The origins of birthstones can be traced back to religious and cultural traditions that predate modern gemology. One of the earliest and most influential references comes from the Book of Exodus in the Hebrew Bible. According to this text, the high priest Aaron wore a breastplate adorned with 12 stones, each representing one of the 12 tribes of Israel. This tradition, described in Exodus 28:15–30, is one of the oldest known connections between gemstones and symbolic meaning.

The exact identities of these stones have long been a subject of debate among scholars. Some translations and interpretations identify the stones as sardius (carnelian), topaz, carbuncle; emerald, sapphire, and diamond; ligure (jacinth), agate, and amethyst; and beryl, onyx, and jasper. These stones were not only symbols of the tribes but also believed to carry spiritual power and protection.

While the breastplate stones were not directly assigned to months of the year, they laid the foundation for later associations between gemstones and specific times or individuals. Over the centuries, this idea evolved, with the stones being linked to the 12 months and the zodiac signs in various cultural contexts.

The Influence of Religious and Cultural Traditions

The transition from the breastplate stones to modern birthstones was not a direct or immediate process. It was shaped by a variety of cultural and religious traditions, particularly in the Eastern and Western worlds.

In the Eastern tradition, gemstones have long been associated with celestial bodies and individual birth charts. Ancient Eastern cultures believed that certain gemstones could influence a person’s fate, health, and spiritual well-being. These beliefs were based on the alignment of celestial forces at the time of a person’s birth. The practice of recommending specific gemstones for specific individuals was an early form of personalized gemstone use, which later influenced the concept of birthstones.

In Western traditions, the idea of assigning gemstones to months and zodiac signs was popularized by scholars such as Flavius Josephus and St. Jerome in the 1st and 5th centuries AD. These scholars associated the 12 stones of the breastplate with the 12 months of the year and the 12 signs of the zodiac. This marked a significant shift in the understanding of gemstones, from symbols of tribal identity to symbols of personal identity and cosmic influence.

By the Middle Ages, the concept of birthstones had further evolved. In some European traditions, gemstones were associated with the 12 apostles of Christianity. For example, Peter was linked to jasper, Andrew to ruby or carbuncle, and James and John to emerald. This practice continued to influence how gemstones were perceived and used throughout the centuries.

The Standardization of Birthstones in the Modern Era

Despite the long history of gemstone symbolism, the modern list of birthstones was not formally established until the early 20th century. This standardization was driven by commercial interests in the jewelry industry, particularly in the United States.

In 1912, the American National Retail Jewelers Association (now known as Jewelers of America) played a pivotal role in defining the official list of birthstones. Their goal was to create a uniform system that could be used across the jewelry trade. The list they established assigned one gemstone to each month of the year. This list was based on a combination of historical references and existing traditions, blending Western and Eastern influences.

The 1912 list included the following assignments:

  • January: Garnet
  • February: Amethyst
  • March: Aquamarine
  • April: Diamond
  • May: Emerald
  • June: Pearl
  • July: Ruby
  • August: Peridot
  • September: Sapphire
  • October: Opal
  • November: Topaz
  • December: Turquoise

This list was a significant step toward unifying the concept of birthstones and making them accessible to a wider audience. It also reflected the growing popularity of gemstone jewelry in the early 20th century.

Subsequent Modifications to the Birthstone List

The 1912 list was not the final version of the birthstone assignments. Over time, additional gemstones were introduced to certain months, often to reflect new discoveries or to expand the range of available gemstones.

In 1952, the Jewelry Industry Council of America added new gemstones to four months:

  • November: Citrine was added as an alternative to Topaz
  • October: Pink Tourmaline was added
  • December: Zircon was added
  • (Some sources suggest other additions as well)

These changes were intended to provide more options for jewelry designers and consumers, reflecting the diversity of gemstones available in the market.

In the 21st century, the birthstone list has continued to evolve. For example, Tanzanite and Spinel have been added to December, and Zircon has gained recognition as a birthstone for December as well. These additions reflect the ongoing influence of the gemstone trade and the desire to create new marketing opportunities.

The Role of Poland in the Popularization of Birthstones

Interestingly, the modern concept of birthstones gained significant traction in Poland before it was fully embraced in the United States. Polish gem traders were among the first to market and sell gemstones based on a person’s birth month. This practice helped to popularize the idea of birthstones as personal and meaningful gifts, which later influenced the standardization efforts in the U.S.

The Polish influence on the birthstone tradition highlights the role of cultural exchange in shaping gemstone practices. It also demonstrates how local traditions can evolve into international standards.

The Commercialization of Birthstones

While the original associations between gemstones and birth months were rooted in spiritual and symbolic beliefs, the 20th and 21st centuries have seen a shift toward commercialization. The standardization of birthstones was, in part, a marketing strategy to encourage the purchase of gemstone jewelry.

This commercialization is particularly evident in the 21st century. For example, in 2002, the American Gem Trade Association (AGTA) added Tanzanite to the list of December birthstones. At the time, December already had two gemstones—Turquoise and Zircon—making the addition of Tanzanite a strategic move to boost sales.

Similarly, in 2006, TanzaniteOne Ltd., a company that sought to control the Tanzanite market, launched a marketing campaign to make Tanzanite a universal birthstone, regardless of the month of birth. Their slogan, "Be Born to Tanzanite," was a clear attempt to expand the commercial appeal of the gemstone.

These examples illustrate how the birthstone tradition has been influenced by economic interests. While the original concept was based on spiritual and symbolic meanings, the modern practice is often driven by marketing and sales strategies.

The Cultural Diversity of Birthstone Traditions

It is important to note that birthstone traditions vary significantly across cultures and historical periods. In Western traditions, the focus has been on biblical and zodiacal associations, while in Eastern traditions, the emphasis has been on celestial influences and healing properties.

For instance, in Tibetan and Indian cultures, certain gemstones were believed to have mystical powers and were worn to harness those energies. These practices were based on the belief that gemstones could influence a person's health, fortune, and spiritual development.

In contrast, Polish and Western European traditions emphasized the symbolic and personal significance of birthstones. These traditions were more focused on the idea of a gemstone as a personal talisman or a symbol of one's identity.

This diversity of traditions underscores the adaptability of birthstone practices. While the modern list of birthstones is largely standardized, the meanings and associations attached to these gemstones continue to evolve.

The Significance of Birthstones Today

Today, birthstones are widely recognized and used in jewelry, both as personal adornments and as meaningful gifts. They are often passed down through generations, serving as heirlooms that carry emotional and familial significance. The popularity of birthstone jewelry has also led to the creation of specialized collections, such as birthstone rings, birthstone necklaces, and birthstone earrings, which are designed to showcase the unique beauty of each gemstone.

In addition to their aesthetic appeal, birthstones continue to be associated with certain metaphysical properties and symbolic meanings. For example, Garnet is believed to bring protection and vitality, Amethyst is associated with calm and clarity, and Emerald is said to promote love and wisdom. These meanings, while rooted in ancient traditions, continue to influence how people choose and wear birthstone jewelry.

The Science Behind Birthstone Selection

While the selection of birthstones is primarily based on historical and cultural traditions, the gemological properties of the stones also play a role in their popularity. Factors such as hardness, color, and availability influence which gemstones are chosen for specific months.

For example, Diamond, the birthstone for April, is highly valued not only for its symbolic significance but also for its exceptional hardness (10 on the Mohs scale) and brilliance. In contrast, Pearls, the birthstone for June, are prized for their lustrous surface and organic origin, making them unique among gemstones.

The availability of certain gemstones in specific regions also affects their selection. For example, Opal, the birthstone for October, is most commonly found in Australia, while Sapphire, the birthstone for September, is often sourced from countries such as Sri Lanka and Madagascar.

The Role of Gemological Organizations

In addition to historical and commercial factors, gemological organizations have also played a role in shaping the modern understanding of birthstones. Organizations such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and the International Gemological Institute (IGI) have contributed to the study and documentation of gemstones, including their historical and cultural associations.

These organizations have also helped to standardize gemological terminology and classification systems, which are essential for accurately identifying and describing gemstones. This standardization has made it easier for jewelers, gemologists, and consumers to understand and communicate about gemstones.

The Future of Birthstones

As the birthstone tradition continues to evolve, it is likely that new gemstones will be added to the list, and existing associations may be reinterpreted. The discovery of new gemstone varieties, such as synthetic gemstones and treated gemstones, has also expanded the range of options available to consumers.

In addition, the growing interest in sustainable and ethical gemstone sourcing is influencing the choices of consumers and jewelers alike. This trend may lead to a reevaluation of the traditional birthstone list, with a greater emphasis on the environmental and social impact of gemstone mining and trade.

Conclusion

The concept of birthstones is a fascinating blend of history, culture, and commerce. While the original associations between gemstones and birth months were rooted in spiritual and symbolic beliefs, the modern list of birthstones was largely shaped by commercial interests in the jewelry industry.

From the breastplate stones of Aaron to the standardized list of 1912, the journey of birthstones reflects the evolving relationship between people and gemstones. The influence of religious traditions, cultural exchanges, and marketing strategies has all contributed to the way we understand and use birthstones today.

As we look to the future, it is clear that the birthstone tradition will continue to evolve, shaped by new discoveries, changing consumer preferences, and the ongoing interplay between science, symbolism, and commerce.

Sources

  1. The Birthstone Earrings Guide
  2. The History of Birthstone Jewelry
  3. How Were the Birthstones Chosen for Each Month?
  4. A Guide to Birthstones
  5. The History of Birthstones

Related Posts